Go Ask Malice Chapter 6, or The (Possible) Murder of Cory Rivkin

Belinda Melbourne from the second book turns up again with the first line of the chapter, asking Rennie if she’s heard what happened to Sunny Silver and Cory Rivkin.  We’ve also met Sunny Silver before in the first book—she’s known as Female Jimi Hendrix in these posts—but Cory Rivkin is someone who’s yet to be introduced, as is whatever’s happened to them.  Along with some description of the “convoy” from the motels, we get some more name-dropping, including Marishka Erzog, who’s just gained a last name and separated “amicably” from Stan Hirsh, the guy who has Rennie’s old job.  Why are all breakups in the Rennie Stride Universe amicable? That doesn’t make for compelling conflict.

Rennie tells her no and feels a blast of fear before going into a combination name-drop/recap of previous book action.  So Cory Rivkin is a musician (naturally), “the drummer for Owl Tuesday, a solid second-rank L.A. band to whom Rennie had given a few bits of good press in days gone by.”  That leads into Rennie shitting on Rose Red Herring one more time.  Rose Red Herring, also known as Rose Noble, was Lionheart’s publicist until Rennie got Turk to fire her because Rennie is terrified of and paranoid about other women who are interested in Turk romantically/sexually.  Rose’s interest is infantilized by being called “a big giant crush” and Kennealy-Morrison uses the beyond-stupid “Turk-crusher-onner.”  This woman used to be a professional writer.

So Rennie decides she needs to stay away from Rose, so she’s not a complete moron.  I just wonder if Rose is aware that Rennie got her fired.  That would be interesting.

Belinda strings out the suspense for a while.  It turns out Sunny almost got hit by an amp and broke her arm.  And we find out “that little groupie” made Rennie a fringed leather sling after she got shot in the third book.  What sad little self-loathing groupie was that? They should all know how much she despises them. She never gets a name and Rennie doesn’t even acknowledge this.  Rennie pushes Belinda a little and gets a portentious look that lets her figure out that Cory’s bought the farm.  Which he has.

Credit where credit is due:  Kennealy-Morrison changed up her usual pattern with the murders.  In the last four books, the murder was always at the end of the chapter and served as a form of cliffhanger to encourage the reader into the following chapter.  The fact that it took five books for this to happen is somewhat less promising.

Belinda expands on what happened.

He was apparently out roaming around the festival, happy as a clam, picked up a cute little groupie—no one anyone knows, and she hasn’t been seen since,, in case you were wondering—

Then how do you know she’s a groupie at all, Belinda? Maybe she’s just a regular festivalgoer who decided she wanted to experience some groovy hippie musician dick.  Oh, yeah, I forgot; groupie is Rennie/the writer’s chosen term of abuse for women who aren’t Queen Emma Peel and have sex with musicians. 

–and he was sitting in the pavilion alternately talking to some people from his label and making out with the chick when all of a sudden he fell over dead.”

Mary Prax suddenly manifests herself in the story with an expression of disbelief before Belinda is allowed to continue Basil Exposition Dumping.

The medical people at the festival who examined Cory after his death said he hadn’t overdosed but don’t rule out any number of other things.  His body’s been taken to the county morgue for an autopsy, but “they” (I guess Belinda means the festival organizers) are “keeping it quiet,” as she says, for fear of fan reaction.  To some guy dropping dead of a heart attack? I doubt it, but I’m sure the reason for the semi-cover-up will become clear later on.

Belinda wonders if it’s “an omen” and that makes Rennie think of Lexicographer, which she brushes off as now the other woman “had an (sic) slightly overinflated sense of her own abilities as it was.”  At least Rennie’s gone back to sniping at women she’s friendly with in her own mind.  I think she slacked off on that in the last book.  Rennie doesn’t want to think it’s a murder yet and they go to the performer’s pavilion.

Again we get Rennie flexing over scoring a performer pass, and find out that this is a means for her of getting one up on Niles Clay.  I’ve decided that since Clay rhymes with Ray, this is the writer’s Ray Manzarek analogue.  And we get a brief foray into third person omniscient POV when Kennealy-Morrison decides to give us more detail about Niles’s feelings on Rennie’s one-upping him somehow.

Rennie wonders aloud whether someone tried to kill Female Jimi Hendrix and Belinda doesn’t know, while assuring her that she doesn’t know any more about what happened to Cory than she’s detailed and calling her Strider.

The performer’s pavilion gets a couple of paragraphs of description and everyone except Rennie goes after food.  Our protagonist takes a glass of champagne, specifically Moet et Chandon, from Ron “Pigpen” McKernan, a member of the Grateful Dead.  Then we get a paragraph or two about how the band likes to spike people’s drinks with LSD and how some of their roadies have spiked a punch bowl in the pavilion.  And then we get yet more evidence that Rennie Stride is a walking Cluster B disorder.

Rennie watched Daily Pillar (sic) columnist Alvy Larrable, one of her least favorite people on the planet and forty years older than just about everybody there, gulp an enthusiastic mouthful before somebody leaned over and obviously warned him, for he instantly spat it out and flung the remainder angrily onto the ground.

With any luck, maybe he’d swallowed enough to start him tripping like a hobo riding the psychedelic rails, the septic creep; could be fun to watch, especially if he started hallucinating he was turning into a taxicab, or a potato chip.

Rennie needs to be in prison more than Danny Marron did.  Note that we haven’t been told about anything Alvy Larrable (which I’m sure is an anagram) did to warrant being called a septic creep and he’s never appeared in the series before this.  No, we’re just supposed to nod along with Rennie like brainwashed zombie worshippers, never questioning her.  Fuck you, Rennie, you Mother of Nightmares.

It surprised me that she does go on to mention the first time she drugged people against their will, at the meeting of the Painted Ladies in the first book and admits she doesn’t have moral high ground about drugging people against their will.  Then she proceeds to frame the entire incident as not her fault, you guys.  No, it was because of her “vile mother-in-law Marjorie” (she isn’t vile at all) and the “stuck-up assemblage of San Francisco’s upper-crustiest dragonesses” (they weren’t, or if they were we got no specifics at all) and Rennie was mad about being forced to wear a Chanel suit (which was one of the pieces of her society-bride wardrobe that she kept, so she must not have minded it too much) and forced to attend the meeting, even though if she’d just acted like an adult and said no she wouldn’t have had to, but she’s a spoiled selfish arrogant child and can’t use her words.  She tries to tell us the LSD was diluted but, interestingly, doesn’t say a word about that in Chapter 10 of the first book when she tells the story, so I’m calling retcon.

She justified taking the champagne with the assertion that she saw Pigpen open the bottle.  According to his Wikipedia page, McKernan was into alcohol, not psychedelics, and there was a whole section in California Screamin’ when Rennie set up a meeting with Jerry Garcia and Pigpen and Becca Revels, who had taken too much acid and her mind was essentially gone.  Pigpen was specifically mentioned in this section as being “disturbed” by this, so the idea that Pigpen would dope her isn’t supported by his past presentation in the series.

Word has gotten around in the pavilion about Cory Rivkin keeling over dead and Rennie does a bunch of projecting over her Murder Chick reputation and getting annoyed.  Well, it is what she does best.  We are also told that Ares Sakura (known in these posts as War God Cherry Blossom), Turk’s bodyguard in the third book, and Mary Prax are still together romantically.  I guess Kennealy-Morrison got tired of sticking same-sex relationships for the bisexual Mary Prax in the spaces between books so she wouldn’t have to write them.

Diego Hidalgo (the Jim Morrison analogue) turns up, and Rennie alludes to wanting to set him up with someone and Mary Prax goes on a misogynist mean-girl rant about someone we haven’t heard of in this entire series, a woman named Portia Paradise who is involved with Diego.  Three guesses as to who this is, even though Mary Prax calls her a “platinum-blonde bimbo we can’t stand” and calls Portia’s name “a nice traditional hooker name.”  Isn’t it cute that she thinks she’s one of the good, non-Evil Blondes?

Then Rennie spiels out a story that seems like a mash-up of the first time she interviewed Jim Morrison and the first time she met Pamela Courson.  As usual, Rennie proves herself a snobby, hateful asshole as she shames Portiapam as being stupid and both she and her lickspittle buddy “scream[] with laughter and pick[] themselves up off the ground.” 

I really would like to know how Kennealy-Morrison thought this would make her female leads look sympathetic and relatable at all, rather than spiteful and immature.

And then we’re gifted with a page and a half about how Portiapam is stupid and using Diego and he only stays with her because it’s comfortable and it’s all straight out of Kennealy-Morrison’s memoir about why Jim never left Pam and does not make anyone involved in this narrative look good at all.

There’s more food talk, some musings on the use of profanity in songs/album covers in the late Sixties, Spencer Dryden of Jefferson Airplane is name-checked, and a historically invalid female head of a record company presents herself:  Dian Cazadora, the head of Sovereign Records.  She’s blonde, so she’s evil, as witnessed when Rennie cuts herself trying to get a wine bottle open and Dian asks why she doesn’t get one of the guys to do it for her.  Rennie doesn’t throw death threats, as is her wont, but here’s what she thought in regard to this question.

Well, up yours, bitch!  But that kind of attitude’s only what I’d expect from someone who’s secretly bonking a Delta blues legend twice her age—and a married one at that…

Hey, slut-shaming!  Where have you been? Long time no see!

Plus, this Delta blues guy is married? You mean like you are, Rennie? I don’t think you have any room to talk, seeing as every time you have sex with your fiancé you’re committing adultery.  Pot, meet kettle.

The next few pages are mainly name-dropping and aggrandizement of Rennie, who managed to score an interview with a character that is obviously Brian Wilson of the Beach Boys.  Funny, I would have thought she’d have complete contempt for them because they aren’t hip enough to suit her, but he’s reclusive and only agreed to speak to her for an interview, so he recognized her essential specialness.  Even so, she does snipe about her “nobly refraining from making him look like the complete wacko he so was.”  Well, he was crazy to talk to you, so I’ll give you that one.

This whole digression about Bisk Hastings (that’s what the Brian Wilson analogue is called) is about a page and a half long and she just goes on and on about how crazy and fat he is.  It’s really hypocritical, but that’s nothing new for her.

Anyway, Rennie’s all excited because she’s at the center of the action and she’s so ultraspecial and these are her people and she’s ready for things to get started.  She has a passing thought about Possible Murder Victim Cory but ain’t got no time for that now.

And—chapter!  I didn’t realize it at the time, but the fourth book didn’t have much in the way of internalized misogyny and slut-shaming because something had to give to make room for all the nobility-fellating.  I would have enjoyed it more if I knew the vacation would come to an end in this book.

It strikes me how much more sympathetic the writer seemed to the festivalgoers in her memoir, but here I think her contempt for people she/Rennie see as beneath her is coming out.  Look at how Turk describes the customers at the Red Apple Rest in the last chapter when the Gruesome Threesome enter the restaurant, “laden forks” and “slack, gaping mouths,” so we get an obesity shot and a stupidity shot in the same sentence.  The exultant speech she has about the festivalgoers being “people like me” is a direct crib from the scene in the first book when she attends the concert at Longshoreman’s Hall in North Beach and finds the hippie scene, but has to be a cut above the people in that scene.  It’s dialed up to eleven here because she’s in the running to be a duchess and her superiority is assured.  I wonder how long it’s going to take her to start investigating whether Cory Rivkin was murdered.  If the last two books are any indication, the killer(s) has at least a month.

Next time, chapter 7, wherein the wheel keeps on spinning, but Patricia Kennealy-Morrison enters the narrative even though she isn’t named, as do War God Cherry Blossom and the asshole Ned Raven of Bluesnroyals, along with the wife he stole from Ross Poldark.

Part the Ninth, or Go Ask Malice

Intro, or the Stuff Before the Book is Opened

Go Ask Malice: Murder at Woodstock is the fifth entry in The Rock & Roll Murders:  Rennie Stride Mysteries.  It was published on December 24, 2012, two years after the publication of A Hard Slay’s Night.  In all the previous books in the series, the month of publication was listed on the copyright page, but is omitted for this book and the rest of the books in the series, as is the ISBN number.  All the books have an ISBN number, which is shown on the Amazon page for each book, along with the publication date, so I’m not sure why Kennealy-Morrison decided to stop printing this information.

I’m also not sure why she published nothing at all in 2011, when the Also By page on the previous book listed both this book and Son of the Northern Star as slated for release, and nothing materialized but this book at the tail end of 2012.  My only guess would be that she ran into writing difficulties with both books.

The title of the book is from a line in the Jefferson Airplane song “White Rabbit,” and was not the original title of the book, as listed on the Also By page for A Hard Slay’s Night.  This is the only book in the series with a title based on a line in a song, rather than a song title.  The original title is listed as Who’ll Stop the Slain, which was a twist on the song “Who’ll Stop the Rain” by Creedence Clearwater Revival, which wasn’t written until 1970.  I understand the decision not to use the original title, as that would have made two books in a row with variations on the word “slay” in the title.

The Also By page for this book again lists her name as Patricia Kennealy Morrison.  The first books listed are the Keltiad series, which is eight books at this point.  After this, Strange Days:  My Life With and Without Jim Morrison is listed, and after that Son of the Northern Star is again listed, with 2013 as the projected publication date.  Then The Rock & Roll Murders: The Rennie Stride Mysteries are listed up to this one, with Scareway to Heaven:  Murder at the Fillmore East listed for publication in 2013, like Son of the Northern Star. 

Neither of these books wound up being published in 2013; Scareway to Heaven came out on October 27, 2014, and Son of the Northern Star never came out at all.  The book Kennealy-Morrison published in 2013 was Rock Chick:  A Girl and Her Music: The Jazz & Pop Writings 1968-1971.  This book has an ISBN number listed and was published July 11, 2013, seven months after Go Ask Malice.  On the Also By page for Rock Chick, the Keltiad is listed in chronological order, rather than in publication order, then Strange Days, then Son of the Northern Star is listed for publication in 2014.  The Rennie Stride books are listed up to Daydream Bereaver, which is listed for publication in 2014, and Scareway to Heaven which hadn’t been published yet.

The biographical information on Rock Chick isn’t the canned bio from the Rennie Stride series.  It lists Kennealy-Morrison as being a “Celtic priestess” and minister in the Universal Life Church, and that she was currently working on “a Viking historical novel, the seventh Rennie Stride mystery, and the final two Keltiad books.”  The last two Keltiad books must be The Beltain Queen and The Cloak of Gold, which were listed as forthcoming back in Love Him Madly.  These never did come out.

Andrew Przybyszewski’s cover for this book is the first one depicting an outdoor location, and the last two books in the series will also have outdoor locations shown.  The main color of the cover is blue, with a dusty blue sky at the top, a green awning and some kind of what looks like a latticework gate to the side of it, with the bottom left side of the cover being filled with people.  They’re more detailed, with more color, than the people on the cover of the last book, but still pretty indistinct.  The central image of the cover is the tree on the right-hand side, which stretches from top to bottom, with gray-brown cracked bark, and a poster attached to it.  There’s no writing on the poster, just what looks like an animal figure on the left-hand side, with its paw bisected by a tear in the poster, and the neck of a guitar on the right-hand side.  Some yellow and red near the bottom of the poster makes it look like a hand is gripping the guitar neck.  The Blood Guitar extends down from the bottom of the poster so the neck lines up, and the bottom of the Blood Guitar is drippy.   It’s still a Fender Stratocaster.

The Psychedelic Art lettering is on the left-hand side of the cover, with magenta lines between the title, subtitle, and author’s name.  The title is in chartreuse-green, the subtitle in kind of a mustardy-gold, and the author name in a blue a couple of shades lighter than the sky.  The series title and subtitle are, as usual, at the bottom of the page in lavender.

The back cover copy begins, as always, “Turn On, Tune In, Drop Dead…”

Three Days of Peace, Music…and Murder

This cover breaks with the pattern established with the rest of the series, which always gave us the location of the book, along with the month and year of the events.  Maybe Kennealy-Morrison thinks we’ll all know when Woodstock happened without being told? For those of us who don’t, it was held at Bethel, New York, from August 15-18, 1969

When Rennie Stride and her friends go off to this summer rock festival in rural upstate New York—a little weekend diversion called Woodstock—the last thing any of them expects to come across is a dead body.  Or two.

I don’t know why not, since Rennie is a well-known murder magnet.  And note that none of her friends are specifically listed by name.  However, we can bet the farm that one of them is Mary Prax.  And I’m curious as to what the kill count for this book will be.  From the previous books, I’d guess between three and five. 

Then the writer calls out the very thing I did in the above paragraph.

Though at this point, of course, it should be the first thing they expect: renowned journalist Rennie—also known as Murder Chick—seems to have a backstage pass to music-biz murder.  And she isn’t afraid to use it.

So does Rennie still hate being called Murder Chick, unless she’s using it about herself in her mind or Turk is using it? And I got a laugh out of the “renowned journalist” fellatio Kennealy-Morrison threw at her self-insert.

But when she encounters rock death on Max Yasgur’s dairy farm, in the middle of half a million people and the greatest rock musicians of the age, and when people she loves get caught up in it, including her own betrothed, superstar guitarist Turk Wayland, she finds herself right back on the front lines once again.

Front lines of what? Murder? Rock music festivals? And I’m finding it amusing that every mystery since she met Turk has to include him.  I don’t know whether the writer knew what she was showing when she made Rennie so reluctant to get off her ass and investigate unless it imperiled her future Duchesshood or otherwise inconvenienced her in some way. 

Or still…

Does the last line mean she never stopped investigating murders? I don’t think that’s really possible, considering there have been six months between the end of the last book and the start of this one.  Unless Kennealy-Morrison decides to throw in more of those non-canonical Winterland/Avalon Ballroom/Human Be-In/the Matrix murders that we never get any other information about.

The author bio is formatted in a manner I don’t like, but it has changed significantly since the last book.  That’s not a surprise, seeing as it’s been two years between books.

Patricia Kennealy Morrison is a retired rock critic—one of the first female rock critics ever, a Founding Mother of the genre—and the former editor of Jazz & Pop Magazine.  An award-winning, two-time Clio-nominated ad copywriter, she is the author of The Keltiad science-fantasy series and the memoir “Strange Days: My Life With and Without Jim Morrison”, (sic)whom she married in 1970.  She attended St. Bonaventure University as a journalism major and graduated from Harpur College (now Binghamton University) with a B.A. in English literature.  She has also studied at NYU, Parsons School of Design and Christ Church, University of Oxford.

She lives in New York City.

This is her fourteenth book and the fifth in the series The Rock & Roll Murders: The Rennie Stride Mysteries.

For whatever reason, the comma after Morrison is outside the double quotes, which I see as incorrect but I don’t know what style manual she was using.  She does keep the author photograph that’s been on the rest of the series, which I find unflattering.  The photographer is back to being listed as Linda Bright.

This is also the first book in the series to have a blurb that’s not a personal testimonial from what we can only assume are personal friends, but seems like it comes from a review in an actual publication.  The blurb is from David Hinckley, who’s credited as a “writer and critic” with the New York Daily NewsI find it better written than the previous blurbs and does call the book “an intriguing and downright charming murder mystery,” in addition to calling out the writer’s experience of the milieu.  I have a feeling my mileage may vary.

The book starts with a two-page Acknowledgements where she admits she not only relief on memory but did research, which is commendable.  The dedication is to Susan Donoghue, whom I think was a personal friend, Pauline Rivelli, who was the founder of Jazz & Pop, and David G. Walley, whom I think was her boyfriend before Jim Morrison.  All of them are dead.

The introductory material of the book concludes with a song by Turk Wayland (as usual), called “Lady of the Lake,” which is too long to be played on the radio in 1969, just like virtually every song that has been given at the front and back of each book.

Next time, the prologue, in which the writer clears her throat and attempts to be portentious about the upcoming music festival.

A Hard Slay’s Night Chapter 11, or You Don’t Mess With the Rennie

We get half a page of summary about what’s just happened with Mary Prax and Rennie giving the story to someone at Baron Hollywood Hogan’s “flagship paper, the London Daily Declarer.”  But in Chapter 21 of Love Him Madly, his flagship newspaper was listed as the Sun-Tribune in New York City.  You can’t have more than one flagship.  And she’s still not italicizing the titles of newspapers but moving on.  She flexes to herself about her Murder Chick rep before heading off to Fortnum’s to have tea with Mary Prax at five-thirty and noting to her friend that “Tea here always calms me down.”  When the hell has she ever been to London in her life? Never, that we’ve been told about.  And she bitches about some people who are having lobster rolls, raspberry sorbet, and hot chocolate, and calls them pigs.  She then goes on, in faux-medieval language, to tell Mary Prax they should get the same order she just called some other people pigs for having.  You’re such a mean-mouthed hypocrite, Rennie.

Again, I stumble over the question of how the writer could think this malignant narcissist would be a charming, appealing character that could sell books, and don’t stumble over an answer to it, just like every other time I’ve wondered about it.  I did run across something interesting about how some narcissists suffer from it because they have massive feelings of insecurity, which would seem to explain Rennie even though Kennealy-Morrison doesn’t give her enough instances of feeling this insecurity internally.

Mary Prax then advises Rennie that she’s renting a house in London for the rest of their stay and tells her that she and War God Cherry Blossom will both be staying there.  Yeah, you gotta have a couple of roommates to kick in with their share of the rent.  You may not be as stupid as I thought, Mary Prax.

Rennie demurs and the matter isn’t settled.  The writer then gifts us with the horrific image of Rennie eating whipped cream with a spoon straight out of the bowl.  The waiter brings new bowls to both of them and they laugh.  Then the waiter goes back to the kitchen to talk about the greedy little American girls who eat nothing but sugar and complains that he knows they’re going to cheap out on his tip because they clearly have no class at all.

Rennie questions Mary Prax about what she told DCI Dakers, as she refers to him, and it’s nothing interesting except that she notes he wanted to know who in Dandiprat she’d slept with.  Rennie calls him “a filthy-minded brute” and tells her he asked her that as well.  Might I remind you, Rennie, you’re the one that was always pinning non-vanilla sex lives on everyone in your orbit, so I think you’re really the one who’s filthy-minded here.

Plus, there has been a double murder involving that band, and they have no real clues as to motive.  Anything could be a clue, so to think he’s asking you two girls about any sexual connections with band members because of his own prurience, rather than as a legitimate attempt to find clues to solve the crime, is just Rennie making herself the center of the universe as usual.

Mary Prax admits to fucking Trevor and Caro Sparrow “both separately and together,” once more keeping any same-sex sexual involvement strictly off-the-page, so Kennealy-Morrison’s still batting a thousand with that.  She also gloats because she thinks she freaked out the cop with that info, which is not likely.  Why do neither of these girls understand that cops have seen more in their working lives than they ever will? 

Then Rennie has a moment of self-perfecting when she clarifies that she fucked Robin Kelloway two years ago before he married his current wife Joanie, and now I’m picturing this guy being married to Erin Moran from Happy DaysThe writer seems to think this takes the stain off her relationship with Robin and makes it something other than adultery, but I have to remind her, Rennie is married to Stephen Lacing, so any sexual relationship she has with another man is adultery.  It doesn’t matter whether the man is married or not—she is. 

And why hasn’t Stephen filed for divorce from her yet, especially since he has a serious relationship underway with a woman who’s a lot more suitable for him than Rennie and her toddler desire to do whatever she wants.

I was flipping through some of the later books and found out that Rennie and Stephen don’t end their marriage until Daydream Bereaver, so effectively not until the end of the series, and they get an annulment, not a divorce.  I can only think this comes from the writer’s early Catholicism, since religion didn’t seem to be an important factor in the life of either participant in the marriage, certainly not to the extent that they wanted to be sure they could marry in the Church again.  But maybe divorce was just too proletarian to suit Kennealy-Morrison.

And finally Mary Prax brings up what the author’s been coy with us about for the entire book:  Rennie’s breakup with Turk. She also calls Rennie “sparklepants.” 

In addition to the reason for the breakup, we’re about to get one heckuva retcon, as is tradition at this point.  Rennie mentions the Winterland Ballroom/Human Be-In murders, as well as a new one at the Jefferson Airplane mansion as having occurred between the end of the third book and the beginning of this one, despite the fact that the Winterland Ballroom and Human Be-In murders was mentioned as having occurred before the beginning of the third book. She also changes the location of the Human Be-In to Griffith Park in Los Angeles. We have to assume the Matrix murder did occur when the writer said, as she hasn’t retconned it yet.  Yeah, the writer doesn’t think anybody’s read any of the books in the series.

Anyway, according to Rennie, Turk doesn’t want her doing her amateur detecting regarding murders, and he also doesn’t want her to be a reporter because he sees that as being dangerous for her and he doesn’t want to lose her the way he lost Tansy, whom he wasn’t even with any more at the time of her murder, but whatever.

This is one of the more realistic conflicts that would occur in a relationship at this time period, if you leave out the Murder Chick danger bullshit.  The man doesn’t want the woman to work.  It wasn’t the norm in Rennie’s middle-class circles and definitely not in Turk’s Richie Rich circles, so he’d want her to conform to what he sees as the norm, just like Stephen did, but at least Turk’s let her know about it before they got married.  And Rennie swears Turk never loved Tansy, which sounds more like reassuring herself than informing Mary Prax. 

But then we get the actual facts:  Turk told her he didn’t know if he could handle a relationship with someone who puts themselves in danger so carelessly and she told him she didn’t know if she could handle his fortune and fame and nobility.

Bullshit!  Those are the most attractive things about him to her!  Some of us have read the entire series up until this point, Ms. Kennealy-Morrison.

Then he got furious—she’d never seen him so angry—and she didn’t get a huge kick out of it this time because she was the target.  In fact, although the author doesn’t frame it this way, she was so frightened of him she went to Mary Prax’s house in the middle of the night to get away from him.  Then we get another two pages about how they’re meant to be together and should make up, with the only interesting thing about this discussion being that Rennie’s still paranoid about other women, making the remarks about “hav[ing] to be on guard against groupies” and “[e]very woman on the planet is competition where he’s concerned,” but she does exempt Mary Prax from this.  In the real world, she’s the one he’d start fucking when he got fed up with Rennie’s crap.

And we get another retcon when Rennie claims she was attacked by groupies in the ladies’ room at a club called the London Fog and she “whaled on” them.  This incident was mentioned in the third book, but it was framed quite differently.  In the third book, these groupies locked her in a stall of the ladies’ room so they could go hit on Turk and she supposedly beat the crap out of them once she got out of the stall.  It sounds like more of a prank on the part of the other women because they’ve perceived how insecure she is in her relationship, but as usual Rennie responds to this with violence.  At least for once it isn’t the usual verbal violence she usually indulges in.

So at the end of the section Mary Prax tells her to go back to him and Rennie demands more whipped cream.   Is that symbolic of something?

In the next section our second terribly-named actress of the series appears (the first was Swannie Rivers).  She was name-checked in the second book (I think), and she is Quinnie St. Clears.  No studio of this time would allow an actress to use a name like either of the above, and this was during the time when the studios had actors under contract and could dictate that sort of thing.  But at least she’s only mentioned in passing and we can move right on by her to Rennie’s hair appointment at “Rene’s of Audley Street.”  Yeah, fuck investigating murders, amirite? It’s not like the word murder is in the subtitle of the book.

So we get a little clothes porn for her (“new herringbone tweed coat with the dark mink trim on its dropped-shoulder seams and cuffs and pockets and facings,” if you’re interested) and once more has trouble with someone in a service position, the way she did with the pixie-style helper in Sarah Jane (fuck you Punkins!) Parker’s “design studio.”  The shop assistant puts her coat away from the other coats and Rennie jumps to the conclusion that it’s because she’s a hippie—although she loudly denied being a hippie in the second book—and her coat isn’t good enough to be associated with the other coats.  It might just be that your coat looks more expensive and the assistant’s tagged you as a bitch who will make a fuss so she’s just being careful, but Rennie is always right and so we have to put up with her judgments on this poor woman, including that Rennie’s coat costs more than this woman makes in half a year and that she’d “stomp right out” because of this if she didn’t need to go to a salon and this is apparently the only one in London that knows how to deal with long hair.

A piece of advice that’s well-known to most people:  when you’re on a date, pay attention to how your date treats the waitstaff because that will tell you a lot about them.  Rennie’s treatment of people she judges as beneath her, which isn’t limited to service employees, indicates she’s haughty and hateful, as does most of what we’ve learned about her to this point.

So now we get a couple of paragraphs about her dithering over the state of her relationship before she distracts herself with murder stories.  In the course of one, Graypaul is described as “Mr. Graham Sonnet, MBE.”  MBE means “Member of the British Empire.”  Does the writer not know that Paul McCartney wasn’t knighted until 1997? The crown was not knighting rock stars in 1968 because they were seen as a bunch of lower-class druggie hooligans and in no way deserving of having a knighthood bestowed on them.  This seems to be just more of the writer jerking off over the British nobility.

Rennie’s pissed off that she doesn’t get any real information in the murder stories and goes on a mental rant about what the point is of publishing stories if the readers don’t get the juicy deets (that’s the gist of it, anyway).  God, how can she be this stupid when the writer does nothing but beat us over the head with how intelligent she’s supposed to be? Maybe the police don’t want to splay their clues all over the front page of the paper because that would let the murderer know how close they are to catching him/her.  You really should be smart enough, or at least have enough experience as a reporter, to know this.

`The next section opens with Rennie going shopping at Biba, because as a hippie there’s nothing she loves more than material possessions.  Here’s what she added to her luggage for the trip home:  “a long gold velour dress, a short red jersey dress, a purple felt gaucho hat, an ankle-length redingote in heavy cream cotton with a buttoned flat front like a cavalry shirt.”  But somehow spending money doesn’t do the trick, so she goes back to the hotel and tries to write but doesn’t have much luck and is “irritated,” as usual, so she bitches about British television programming as she needs the TV on to write.  Wasn’t there a murder? Shouldn’t there be detecting happening?

Rennie starts trying to rationalize her amateur detecting, of course.  Where would the book be if she minded her own business and tended to her broken romantic relationship?

…not even when the Yard had seemed to hint that she had something to contribute.

When did this happen? All I remember is DCI Dakers telling her to keep her nose out of the case because Scotland Yard doesn’t tolerate amateur detectives.  So, in keeping with what she’s been told by the authorities, she starts going over her theories about what happened to Celandine and Allen Goodwyn, admitting that she and Celandine weren’t actually friends.  Is it really that hard to keep track of what you write from one chapter to the next?

Anyway, she thinks Celandine was “collateral damage” and not anyone who’d been a target.  Allen Goodwyn was definitely a target, but even though he was reputedly a drug dealer, she can’t figure out why he would have been murdered, or why Graypaul would have been attacked.  So this encounter with mortality inspires her to call Turk to come over to the hotel and fuck her, which he does in very short order.  Once again, everything is about Rennie.

And—chapter!  It feels like nothing is happening because there’s all this focus on the romance and it’s pulling attention away from the murders.  Plus, I don’t like the retconning of the murders because it’s outright sloppy and indicates the writer doesn’t have much respect for the reader whom she’s hoping to induce to buy her books.  I can’t help but think more familiarity with the genre would have helped her.

Next time, chapter 12, in which we spend the entire chapter in bed with Rennie and Turk.  He does get a little bit of POV time but calling him a “co-protagonist” is way off.

A Hard Slay’s Night Chapter 10, or Basic Bad Instinct

Kennealy-Morrison does her trademark time-skip at the beginning of the chapter, which takes up the entire first section.  The only things of interest we’re told is that Caro Sparrow (pronounced care-o spare-o) is a childhood friend of Celandine’s, because it’s so much easier to tell than to show for a writer, that there is a second murder victim, and that Graypaul was the person who fell down in the back of the hall because somebody shot him.  Yeah, can’t have one of the victims be some nobody, amirite? Rennie calls Graypaul and Celandine her friends, but it seems more like she means acquaintances because there’s been no actual friendship indicated here, especially with Celandine.

The next section starts out by informing us that the second murder victim (the one hanging from the chandelier) is Allen Goodwyn, not much of a surprise since Rennie hated him for no reason other than that he was a cokehead, which is something she could lay claim to as well if one remembers her coke-fueled assault on a cop in the last book, for which she suffered exactly zero consequences.  At least Allen Goodwyn didn’t beat up cops while he was high on cocaine.

And the writer calls the second victim “the unauthorized chandelier pendant.”  Nice.  Real nice.  I don’t care what kind of book Albert Goldman was writing.

Then the entire rest of this section is the logistics of getting people home from the venue, which no reader gives a popcorn fart about.

Rennie does mention the seventh guiser and the edge on the sword but nobody really gives a crap and she says she’ll tell the cops tomorrow.  Yeah, because catching a killer can certainly wait.  Why didn’t you tell the cops who showed up at the venue that there was a seventh person dressed as a morris dancer? Because fuck us, that’s why.

My preliminary theories on why the victims died:  Celandine was the killer’s accomplice and made the seventh guiser outfit for him (assuming the killer’s a man here because it’s been a theme in this series that women will do anything for a man, including commit murder) and he had to kill her to cover his tracks.  Allen Goodwyn died because he’s part of the country-house burglary ring and the killer’s trying to get rid of his own connections to the crimes.  Right now I’m thinking the murderer is probably either Cleve Farris or Balto Wallace.  Or Saccharine Shootingwoods. We’ll see.

So Rennie wakes up from a nightmare about being murdered and we find out she’s on Valium.  It’s already number seven on the list of drugs Rennie’s taken in the series and so doesn’t need to be listed again.  This is another time-skip, as we find out when we’re whipsawed back to what she did when she got back to her room the night before.  All these time-skips are bad technique, but moving on.

What did she do the night before? Write up a “short piece” on the murders and call the Clarion to run it.  So she made a transatlantic long-distance call.  Okay, sure, if it was one AM when she finished with the story and called them, it would be five PM in San Francisco.  I don’t know when the last edition of the paper would run, but it could at least be in the morning edition.  But they tell her to go to Baron Hollywood Hogan’s main offices in Fleet Street and tell them.  She thinks about wearing her “new Chloe dress.” 

But important things first:  she calls up the castle/priory to find out how Graypaul is and make sure all her sucking-up wasn’t a waste of her time.  Fortunately for her, he is, and he and Pruelinda will come back the next day in all kinds of fancy rich-person style arranged by Saccharine Shootingwoods, with War God Cherry Blossom accompanying them.

Closing out the section is some clothes porn for Rennie (“mushroom-gray Chloe lace minidress and shiny brown leather thighboots and a fur-trimmed coat all topped off with a feather-and-leather Cavalier hat,” if you’re interested).  I think I’ve seen this very hat in pictures of Kennealy-Morrison.  It was a pretty hat, by the way.  And “thighboots” is two words.  Most people would write “thigh-high boots.”

The next starts with Rennie at New Scotland Yard, rather than the newspaper offices.  She’s being interviewed by “Detective Chief Inspector Gordon Dakers” and, as I suspected, she displays all the charm and cordiality we’ve learned to expect.

…[ the cop’s] eyes contracted the tiniest bit as he observed her attire, from feathers right down to boots, and Rennie suppressed the desire to grab him by his collar and shake him like a rat.  You could see he thought she looked like someone Jack the Ripper should have taken care of long ago, in a perfect, well-ordered world.  Well, he was going to change that tune, and right speedily too, at least if she had anything to say about it…

Hey, Rennie, you’re the one who dressed yourself this morning—oh, pardon me, it was noon before you got up.  You’re almost twenty-five years old, therefore your frontal lobe is almost finished developing, and you knew you were going to see the police.  So you dressed like you were going clubbing.  Okay.  And where’s your actual evidence that Dakers (and I think that’s an anagram but have no patience for it) thinks you’re a whore? His eyes made a movement? Try presenting that as proof in a court of law.  Rennie has a chip on her shoulder about cops—the only thing a cop can do to win her approval is to shower her with praise and make her part of an active investigation.

Dakers makes a remark that indicates he’s aware of her Murder Chick reputation and she says something snotty about the “new headquarters” being “in a state of disarray,” which at least shows the writer knew the organization moved to a new building the year before this.  He registers it but says nothing except a very appropriate statement that New Scotland Yard doesn’t encourage “amateur detectives.”  Bullseye, and Rennie is the most amateur of the amateur.  Inspector Dakers and Graypaul are in the running for my favorite character, and he likes Rennie too much to be the winner.

The next eleven pages are Rennie matching “wits” with the Detective Inspector.  Of course Rennie comes out on top, despite mouthing off to him relentlessly and showing him not the slightest respect, and this only happens because she’s the author’s self-insert.

She retorts to him, “I think I forfeited my amateur status some time ago, Detective Inspector,” in what I can only envision as an exceptionally snotty manner.  He has a lot of restraint to keep himself from saying, “So you get paid to solve crimes, then? If not, you’re an amateur, you spoiled, selfish, arrogant child.”  But he lets her rattle on with more of her self-aggrandizing monologuing which once again includes her married name (why get married if you can’t leverage your elevated social status against the proles) and her professional name.  I think she just gets a thrill out of shocking the normies, or at least thinking she’s shocking the normies.

So she brags about how she’s probably done this more often than they have—not likely—and we get a long, long, long recap of what’s happened in the book up until this point.  This is so boring I can’t even convey it.  We do get a whole paragraph about Dakers having heard from the cops she’s worked with, which presumably includes Marcus, about “this young woman—intelligent, incredibly perceptive, equally incredibly annoying,” and a reference to the Tarrant family that brings up Rennie/the narrator’s use of the word ancient.

Number of times Rennie/the narrator says ancient: 8

Dakers has also figured out her connections, both personal and professional, which puts her beyond any ability of his to discipline.  Sorry about that, Detective Inspector.  But at least you didn’t have to fuck her like Marcus did, so count your blessings.

We also find out there’s some guy named Packy, or Patrick O’Neill, is part of the band and has never been mentioned until now.  Wonder if he’s the killer.  He’s the only one with an obviously Irish name and we’ve already had a clue about a midwinter ritual, and Kennealy-Morrison had Irish ancestry.  We’ll see.

And I get the news that Clemence Dane, Dandiprat’s lead singer, is a woman.  What the hell? I went back through the book and can’t find one single reference to Clemence/Clemmie being a woman, except maybe when Caro Sparrow’s referred to as the other female singer.  I have to say that’s a pretty big piece of information to be withheld until chapter 10.

There’s a lot of grilling about exactly where she was and exactly what happened and why she did things that is just as boring as the other times Rennie’s been interrogated by the police in past books.  We get some background about Celandine—real name, where she was from, that sort of thing—and that her “friendship” with Rennie doesn’t predate Monterey Pop.  And Punkins Parker’s real name is Sarah Jane, so I guess Kennealy-Morrison was also a Doctor Who fan.  And there’s an actress named Swannie Rivers mentioned here, whom I would never hire for anything at all based on her stupid stupid name.

Rennie takes offense at questions about her past relationship with the band and tries to shock them by admitting she fucked Robin Kelloway, back in the first book when he was the guitarist.  Then she makes a Beatles reference that he doesn’t pick up on and she starts mocking his musical taste.  As a trained professional, he doesn’t react.  She should take a lesson or two from him.

Rennie asks him to tell her what he thinks happens and he does, and she instantly thinks he’s a lot nicer but doesn’t make the mental connection that this is because he’s doing what she wants.  What a little narcissist.   Anyway, he doesn’t know why Allen Goodwyn was killed and thinks Celandine was a witness and was killed so she couldn’t prevent the murderer’s getaway.  Since she was stabbed with the sword and strangled with her choker, this is obviously wrong, as it would take time the killer wouldn’t want to lose, but he has to be wrong so Rennie can look smarter and preen herself over her own intelligence. 

She ventures some theories about the killer living in the area as he didn’t take public transport and no cab driver picked up anyone in the area, and the costume was found in the garbage near the river.

And—chapter!  Rennie’s arrogance and narcissism really go into overdrive anytime she comes into contact with someone who has authority.  She presented herself as so arrogant and hostile to Inspector Dakers that he ought to take a good hard look into whether she might be the murderer.  But of course she’ll be embraced by the police and included in the investigation as a tribute to her obvious superiority and, need we say, her intelligence.

Next time, chapter 11, in which Rennie spends some time chewing on the facts of the murder case and more time talking to her BFF about Turk.

A Hard Slay’s Night Chapter 9, or Death Falling on Celandine

This chapter is headlined “Tuesday, December 31,” and we start out at the Royal Albert Hall for the Dandiprat show.  Rennie’s wearing “furs,” which I assume is that fox fur coat she so worshipped when it was first mentioned, and once again shows her love of the trappings of wealth.  She also spends the next few paragraphs raving over how well-dressed and rich and grand everything and everyone is, overusing adverbs in the process.

Rennie’s sitting “in the front grand tier box…which made her feel like Victorian high society.”  Social status seems very important to her at all times. Then we find out she knew and liked most of the people in the twelve-seat box and get a roll call of all the fancy people around her that takes up an entire page.  Since I don’t know who’s going to be important in this book or future books, I’ll include it.

…Sovereign Records head of publicity Dian Cazadora…Pie Castro, head of Battyfang Unlimited, personal flack for Prax and Evenor, who had now taken on Lionheart and Dandiprat and the Sonnets…

At this point we get a little mini-recap about Lionheart’s former publicist, Rose Noble (known in these posts as Rose Red Herring), whom Turk fired because she had a crush on him and Rennie was such a paranoid insecure bitch that he knew he couldn’t handle her jealousy as long as Rose worked with him, even though he knew beforehand that his publicist had a crush on him and didn’t especially care.  This whole thing did give me a little insight into what I think is the writer’s view on why a rock star would cheat on his girlfriend.  Not just because he’s a man in his mid-twenties who’s been catapulted into stardom and may or may not have the internal resources to handle it, not because he just doesn’t want to settle down yet, not just because he may not be in love with anyone at this point in time, not even that some men just can’t be faithful—it’s the women.  In her mind, the gravitational pull of a woman’s desire—not just a beautiful woman or a successful woman, any woman—will inevitably pull that man to her and sex will ensue.  The man doesn’t want to cheat.  It’s the vicious, villainous, sexual groupie trash sluts who force him to cheat!  He is blameless. We’re also advised that Rose Red Herring is safely “back in New York,” where she can’t threaten Rennie anymore.  I have to say, Turk is not nearly as smart as the writer thinks if he will indulge this level of jealousy and insecurity.

And back to the name drops!

…Sovereign label president Leeds Sheffield…Prue Sonnet…Carson Duquette…his [Leeds] eleven-year-old daughter Jessica…

It would be cool if the eleven-year-old was the killer, but Rennie doesn’t hate her, so she can’t be.

Mary Prax and War God Cherry Blossom are also there, engaging in indecorous public displays of affection, and the last chair is empty.  Of course, it’s for Turk and Rennie’s all kinds of disappointed that he isn’t there because she’d expected him to be and her resolve’s faltering.  Maybe he’s being a gentleman and giving you enough space to decide what you want, Rennie.  A lot of women would think highly of that.  Then she has a flashback to seeing Lionheart perform at Monterey Pop in the second book but it’s only a paragraph long so it’s not unbearable.

Rennie bitches about Cleve Farris’s gladhanding and credits the new manager for being more decorous and we get a sudden shift into another scene before the section ends, a short two paragraphs where we find out that one of the chandeliers has gone out and is casting shadows into one corner, and they decide to turn on a different one and check it after the show.

The next section gives us almost three pages about Dandiprat’s performance, comparing them to the bands Fairport Convention and Steeleye Span and describing their musical style, which was described in the first book as “Elizabethan-rock.”

heavy-metal folk rock: wonderful, ancient ballads—

Number of times Rennie/the narrator says ancient:  6

–backed by a pounding hard-rock accompaniment…traditional songs and sea chanteys that had been their folky stock in trade and marry them to howling riffs and crashing power chords and Yggdrasil bass lines and drums of thunder…

Fun fact:  the phrase “heavy metal” is best remembered for its use in the Steppenwolf song “Born to Be Wild,” but no usage of it predates 1967.  I think this is an anachronistic use, but it’s gray area.  And now back to our regularly scheduled snark.

I think Geoffrey Snow is the Dandiprat bassist, since that seems to be the only position left.  We’ll see.

And somebody plays the bagpipes in this band.

So the morris dancers come out on stage after the “bagpipe and guitar finale” (man, that sounds eardrum-bursting) and Rennie connects with its pagan origins, although the writer’s still playing coy enough with “Rennie isn’t me” that she won’t come straight out with it. 

Number of times Rennie/the narrator says ancient:  7

Okay, the way this is presented it seems like the members of Dandiprat are doing the morris dancing, which definitely wasn’t made clear enough earlier on.  Everybody looks the same in the outfits but Pruelinda recognizes Graypaul.  The “guisers” go out into the aisle and pull people out of their seats to dance.  Boy, everybody in the rock world is rude as shit.  At the stroke of midnight everybody starts celebrating, and we find out that there were “special New Year’s crackers that had been left on every seat.”  And, just in case you think these are saltine crackers, “the explosive pops of the party favors echoing like gunfire or champagne corks going off.”

The gunfire reference is way too obvious.  Most of the time where someone describes gunfire that they didn’t know was gunfire at the time, they say it sounded like firecrackers.  I wrote a story once about a school shooting and someone who was reading it said he knew exactly what was about to happen the moment the lead character said she heard firecrackers.

Unsurprisingly, somebody at the back of the hall falls down and doesn’t get up.  Panic spreads—why? Hasn’t anybody checked this person to see if they’ve had a heart attack, or just passed out drunk? And there’s something on the left-hand side of the hall that inspires Rennie to start running for the action, because she can’t bear not being the center of attention. 

War God Cherry Blossom’s ahead of her, and Mary Prax and Pruelinda are following Rennie.

So something’s hanging in the chandelier, since we didn’t get enough of hangings in Love Him Madly.  Rennie noticed there were seven people in the morris dancer outfits where there should have only been six but doesn’t try to pursue them and find the killer because that would make too much sense.  She has no reason why she’s running up there and panicking but doesn’t care.  War God Cherry Blossom tries to hold her back, but Rennie does get enough of a look at the victim to see that it’s Celandine Vervain, who is a definite case of overkill.

…spread out on the carpeted floor like a butterfly pinned to a board.

I guess they cut her down? It’s a mistake to make a reader guess about this sort of thing.  The writer did a better job with the same thing in the last book. And what about the person in the back of the hall who fell down? That occurred before people started pointing up to where something was hanging. This is unclearly written.

Her face was hidden by her tumbled hair, and her trademark choker was, horribly, living up to its name.  She was wearing one of Punkins’ patchwork velvet dresses—only, Punkins would never have put so many ugly dark red patches into it, and she certainly hadn’t put in that really big patch right in front.

And she absolutely wouldn’t have put in the sword.

And—chapter!  Oh, this book is a slog.  I know I say that every time, and I will stop saying it the moment it stops being true.  From the back cover copy, it sounded like the entire book, or at least half, would be at the country-house party and the Dandiprat concert would be the dramatic climax.  Instead, we’re on page 90 (out of 362, not including the Lionheart song and the “Lineage of the Tarrant Family” section, about which I do not give a shit) and we’ve gotten our first murder, and both of the events on the back cover are finished.  I feel like this book is very poorly paced, which is another of the flaws of the author’s work when not in the space fantasy genre.

Next time, chapter 10, wherein Rennie gets grilled by Scotland Yard and is just as charming and cooperative as one might expect, given her past performance in the series.

A Hard Slay’s Night Chapter 8, or Fun with Turk and Rennie

After lunch, Rennie and the gang toddle off to the Royal Albert Hall so Dandiprat can do a sound check.  This made me question the story’s timeline, so I had to go back and check it.  Today is December 30, 1968, so it’s the day before Dandiprat’s show.  Kennealy-Morrison just dates chapters if there’s a change in the date between them, which I didn’t notice prior to this.

Rennie and Mary Prax and Turk and War God Cherry Blossom sit around listening to the sound check, which I can’t imagine is very interesting, and discussing either uninteresting topics or having their conversation summarized as it is uninteresting.  We get some more members of Dandiprat—how many members does this band even have?  Here’s the current lineup.

  1. Clemence Dane, lead singer
  2. Robin Kelloway, keyboard player (in Ungrateful Dead he was the guitarist)
  3. Geoffrey Snow, position still undisclosed
  4. Trevor Sparrow, drummer
  5. Caro Sparrow (oh, brother), female singer and wife of drummer, so backup singer? Whatever.
  6. Jamie Palfrey, guitarist

Rennie messes around with the morris dancer costumes and we have what I believe is a clue about seeing some of the costumes at Pomander when they’re all finished and at the theater.  So now we know why she had to go there to buy a new dress when she should have packed one in advance. The killer presumably has an accomplice at the “design studio” and is having a costume made for himself so he can get close enough to make a kill.  We’ll see how that goes.  Rennie’s also messing around with the swords and expressing suspicions of anything and everything.  Geoffrey makes her quit messing around with the swords, so maybe he’s the killer since he prevented her from doing something she wanted to do?

Then we find out from Caro Sparrow that Graypaul is going to be one of the “guisers,” so I guess he’s the target? We know he’s not the killer because Rennie would look like a fool to have spent all this time kissing up to a murderer.  Everybody’s onboard with Graypaul kicking a dancer out of their position, including the dancer, because the rich and famous are just soooooo much better than the plebeians, amirite?

After the sound check, War God Cherry Blossom and Mary Prax depart, leaving Turk and Rennie alone.  Dum dum DUM!

So he asks her to get back together, she says no and leaves, and—chapter!  Next time—what? What do you mean that isn’t all? That’s the gist of it!  Come on!

Well, if I must.

Turk does ask her to talk with him, she doesn’t agree, and he grabs her arm—Servant series Wesley flashback!  Oh wait, he “took” her arm like Morty and “steered” her across the street before “hustling” her to the Albert Memorial.  It’s all good with Rennie because we know how much she likes it when men don’t let her make her own decisions and ignore what she wants.  She gets moderate flaming panties—smoldering panties?—for him before he abases himself completely before her in an attempt to get her back.  Without knowing why they broke up, which Kennealy-Morrison still hasn’t told us, we can’t know whether this level of abasement is justified.

“I’m desperately sorry I let you walk out in LA.  I was wrong.  I was a prat and a moron and an utter idiot, and I apologize profoundly for being so.  I love you and I miss you and I want you back.”

I just remembered that Patricia and Jim had a huge fight in Los Angeles and she went back to New York, and I believe that was the last time she ever saw him.  And Jim never said anything like that to her, according to her memoir.  But perfected author self-insert, you know.

Rennie mentions the second side of Lionheart’s new album, which was released on the anniversary of the Pearl Harbor attack (which I find amusing), and it’s already been mentioned it’s all love songs about her, and he takes this as evidence that she knows he’s really really sorry for whatever he did. 

Then she manifests her paranoia and hypervigilance by taking him to task for his supposed engagement to a “trashy Italian countess” whom she also calls a “Euroslut.”  Oh, slut-shaming, it’s been so long!

Turk laughs his head off because he and the countess had a publicity date and they are not engaged.  And this is why he never should have gotten involved with Rennie romantically.  She’s pathologically jealous and can’t deal with fans, who are all groupies to her if they’re women, or gossip or rumors.  In the third book, he even had a moment where he explained to her that he only dates other celebrities because they understand what’s involved with dating a rock star.  Rennie got all offended at this, but she should have listened to him because the last person she should be dating is someone who has female fans who want to sleep with him.

Rennie tells him things aren’t going to change because she won’t stop being a reporter or behaving stupidly enough to get herself killed (in different language, of course) and he says he doesn’t care anymore because he wants her too much to give a shit if she gets herself killed (in different language, of course).

Then we get four paragraphs about this incredible, amazing love song he wrote to her called “Svaha,” which is the song that appears after the author’s note and acknowledgements at the beginning of the book and is too long for radio airplay in 1968.  Turk even says it’s eleven minutes long, so this is not a song he ever expects to be a hit.  I wonder what the other guys in the band think about this. For those of you who are curious, the author gives the meaning of the word svaha (which is credited as Viking/Norse) as the moments between the lightning and the thunder.

After the four paragraphs about the song, Rennie tells him she misses his beard, which I guess means those incoherent things she said about his hair and beard at the ball indicated that he’d shaved and cut his hair, which wasn’t mentioned at the time.  There’s a Jim Morrison allusion when it’s mentioned that the public didn’t like the beard and long hair when Turk first grew them, and Rennie dunks on “teenyboppers” for being too stupid to like what she likes.  Then she decides she’s gotta go, he tries to stop her but stops himself, and she takes a cab but the hogs don’t eat her.

We have one final paragraph backstage at the Royal Albert Hall, where everything’s ready to go for Dandiprat’s performance the next day, and the robes rustle but then are still, which is atmospheric but doesn’t really do anything for the plot.

And—chapter for real!  This is one of the shorter posts I’ve done in this series because NOTHING FUCKING HAPPENS IN THIS CHAPTER!  Mostly it’s Turk trying to get back with Rennie and her not getting back with him despite how much she wants to and the reason for the breakup being concealed.  Since I don’t have any investment in one single character in this book, all the non-murder material is just torturous. 

Next time, chapter 9, in which Dandiprat plays its New Year’s Eve show at the Royal Albert Hall and we finally finally finally get our first murder of the book.

Love Him Madly Chapter 20, or Cool Hand Turk

In this chapter, Rennie does the single stupidest thing she has ever done in the series, let alone this book.  I want to say that it’s the single stupidest thing she ever will do in the series, but I highly doubt it.  It’s kind of impressive that this single action encapsulates every flaw that Rennie has as a character, but the writer thinks it’s her being brave and rebellious and daring (Future Me:  don’t worry, there will be no real consequences for either of them over this incident, which makes this entire chapter pointless).  Not only was what Rennie did stupid in 1968, it’s stupid right now.  You wouldn’t do it, I wouldn’t do it, nobody would do it because it’s stupid.  But we’ll get there.

So they wake up in the morning and the next two pages is about Rennie expositing about what she’s learned concerning what Turk is like, and a lot of it is contradictory, but what else did we expect? She flashes some more literary cred that she shouldn’t have, as she isn’t a lit major and we’ve seen her glance at one book in the entire series.  This time the reference is something I found obscure:  Lawrence Durrell’s Balthazar, the second volume of the Alexandria Quartet, namely the line, “Nobody can own an artist, so be warned.”  So props for coming up with a deep cut reference, Ms. Kennealy-Morrison.

The next section begins after lunch, with them having been to “some tastings” at vineyards.  There’s the implication that they’re at least buzzed, even though the object of wine tasting isn’t to get drunk.  Turk seems relaxed and confides in Rennie that this is the first time in months he doesn’t think they’re being watched.  It’s good they’re not, because Rennie’s been giving him a blowjob while he drives, as her head was in his lap and “she’d been happily busy for that silent mile.”  This kind of makes it seem like Rennie wants to die in a car accident, as witness the earlier cocaine-snorting while driving feet away from an un-guardrailed thousand-foot drop.

Turk tells her they’re being followed by a cop, then makes a “witty” remark about a moving violation and instructs her to “lose the coke.”  Rennie then

…coolly unfolded the little tinfoil packet she’d had in her bag and snorted most of its contents, letting the rest blow away.

It might have been useful to us, in view of later events, to know exactly how much Bolivian marching powder Rennie snorted here. 

Rennie watches the cop get out of his patrol car and it’s just one deputy sheriff.  That seems more like now than then, because back at the end of the Sixties patrol cops largely weren’t depicted as being alone.  Then again, what’s about to happen wouldn’t have happened the way it’s written if the cop had a partner with him.

In this section, Rennie gets rid of the foil “invisibly.”  This weakness of her writing style is really annoying me and has been for a while.  Overuse of adverbs indicates that the writing itself is weak, because if the writer had confidence that what she means has been conveyed, she wouldn’t feel the need to use all these adverbs, especially in the dialogue tags.

She’s freaking out about him getting arrested, then decided it’s better to get “busted” (which also means arrested) for the driving blowjob than what they did when they were high on pot the night before.  Rennie described this as something they’d heard Mick Jagger did with Marianne Faithfull once, which amounted to the guy eating a candy bar out of the woman’s vagina, which is all I can determine from Kennealy-Morrison’s arch language.  But she goes on at length about how messy it was (they were stupid enough to use a chocolate candy bar) and how it stained the “fearfully posh Pratesi bed linen” and worries about what the maids will think but then just start laughing because consequences are for ordinary people.

The deputy sheriff is presented with all speed as one of those small-town cops who hate hippies after Turk asks, “Can we help you, officer?”  He implies the Porsche must be stolen and asks for Turk’s license and registration, with which he “promptly” complied.  We should note that Turk is being calm and collected here.  Why is he behaving this way? Well, if Lionheart really does have all that “fabulous success” the writer insists on, they’ve been touring for a long time.  They may be successful enough for a private plane now, but before they got there they used a tour bus.  Traveling that way, they must have passed through areas of the country where the general population hates them some commie pinko longhaired dirty hippies and they were certainly hassled by the cops.  Bob Seger‘s song “Turn the Page” is about road touring in the Seventies and mentions this attitude. Turk is used to this and knows that if he just stays calm, the cop will work out his aggression and let them go.  It’s an inconvenience, but nothing serious.

Rennie notices the cop looking at her bare legs briefly and has earlier decided that Turk’s name doesn’t mean anything to him.  I find that hard to believe, since Kennealy-Morrison has harped on how famous Lionheart and Turk are, and he just got arrested for murder.  I’d think that would be more than a blip on any cop’s radar.  It’s implicit that she’s figured out, “Do you know who I am?” won’t do any good coming from Turk.  Turk gets out of the car when the cop tells him to and Rennie proceeds to fuck the situation up beyond all recognition.

Kennealy-Morrison makes sure to blame this entire upcoming incident on Rennie’s “suddenly cocaine-enhanced temper kindling at the edges—little warning curls of smoke rising in the sunlight of the forest glade, all the furry woodland creatures fleeing for their lives.”  Then maybe she shouldn’t have snorted that cocaine, because maybe, just maybe, it might be a good idea to have her wits about her when dealing with the police.  Not all of them are Marcus Dorner.  And Turk didn’t tell her to snort it—he just said to lose it.  Since she let some of it blow away, she could have done that with all of it, but the writer wanted to have an excuse for Rennie to act like a complete fool so as not to damage her ability to preen over her own intelligence.

So Rennie asks the cop what’s going on and gets the information that they did get pulled over for the blowjob and he slut-shames her. 

You do that for all the pansy longhairs in fancy cars? Pretty thing like you, tits like those, you’re wasted on them—how about doing it for a guy with a nice big nightstick? What’s your name, honey?

Rennie doesn’t like slut-shaming when she’s getting it instead of giving it and loses her shit.  Then maybe you should have kept your mouth shut and let Turk handle it, since he has experience with this kind of thing and you absolutely don’t.  And Kennealy-Morrison—oh, pardon me, the cop—gave her the perfect set-up to make a little “Do you know who I am?” speech.

“My name? My name is Lacing.  Mrs. Stephen Lacing.  Perhaps you’re familiar with it? My husband’s family owns that little shack over in Calistoga called Whiteoaks.  As for your charming suggestion, I wouldn’t put my mouth near any oinky police part of you for all the farms in Cuba.  I’d need lye for a mouthwash.  Good thing you’ve got that nightstick to help out, ‘cause I bet you can’t get it up with a splint.  And finally, I am most definitely not your honey.  I’m his honey.”

Rich person privilege, your table is ready!  And it just gets worse.

Officer Nighstick yanks Rennie out of the car and Turk is duty-bound to protect her, although the only thing he does here is slap the cop’s hand off her.  And he was actually yanking her by the hair and the arm, so I’d think he had both hands on her but whatever.

I can’t imagine how emasculating this entire experience must be for Turk.  His girlfriend has used her current husband’s name to try to protect both of them, as she isn’t content to let him handle the situation, and he’s been forced to assault a cop to protect her from the consequences of her own actions.  Keep in mind that one of the things Rennie listed as a problem with Stephen was that he “didn’t protect” her.  And, eventually, it will be Rennie’s connection to the Lacing family that keeps them from experiencing any real consequences for assaulting a police officer, even though Turk is out on bail for murder.

Anyway, the cop grabs Turk and throws him across the hood of the car, whereupon Rennie kicks Officer Nightstick in the nuts.  She is so fucking stupid.  But then we have the audience-pleasing moment, which is unfortunately summarized, where the cop maces both of them in the face.  They should both count themselves lucky that he didn’t fracture their skulls with said nightstick, put them in the Porsche, and send it over a cliff.  As long as they didn’t have any bullet wounds, it would be a good plan.  It’s a convertible, so the coroner would expect a lot of injuries from hitting the rocks.  Any autopsy would reveal they both had alcohol in their systems, along with cocaine on Rennie’s part, and they’d just rubber-stamp it as accidental death.  And the series would be over.

When the next section starts, the writer tells us:

…the deputy actually drew his gun and kept it pointed at them while he radioed for backup.

Why is the writer using the adverb “actually” here, as if it’s a ridiculous thing that a cop who just got assaulted by two people during a traffic stop would use his gun to reestablish control of the situation and protect himself? They’re just both lucky he didn’t shoot them.

In between when Officer Nightstick radioed for help and help gets there, he does a lot of insulting of both Turk and Rennie, and Rennie retaliates by threatening to castrate him if his dick weren’t so small she couldn’t find it, in what the author refers to as “sprightly ad hoc riffs.”  You can tell Kennealy-Morrison never had a real interaction with the police in her life that amounted to more than a friendly warning.

So two other cops show up, and we’re told that Turk and Rennie are “still half-blind from the Mace.”  Funny, she sounded a lot more “sprightly” than that when she was making physical threats against Officer Nightstick.

When they get to the station, Rennie calls Eric to bail them out and Turk spends a couple of hours signing autographs, which right there blows that whole “hick deputy doesn’t know a rock star” theory out of the water.  Eric shows up and, being a Rennie-worshipping shit, doesn’t set her straight on how she almost got both herself and her true love shot in the head but is amused by the entire incident, which no homosexual man in 1968 would be, as they would be cognizant of the dangers in standing up to cops.  That’s why the Stonewall uprising the next year was such a milestone for the LGBTQIA movement.

Of course, since this is Queen Mary Sue, Officer Nightstick has to suffer a comeuppance for his behavior.  This is such a Mary Sue wish-fulfillment fantasy I’m feeling second-hand embarrassment for the author because nobody succeeded in having her dial it back enough so that they might experience just a few consequences of their own actions.  So Rennie’s a bitch when she speaks to Officer Nightstick, which is no surprise at all, and Eric clamps a hand over her mouth and picks her up to get her out of his vicinity before she calls him a pig again.  And this is treated as humorous.

Eric and Trey have them to dinner and this entire section is nothing but talking about heirs and cooking and Rennie spewing venom about Marcus.  Eric calls him an idiot because what’s family compared to fellating Queen Mary Sue who almost got herself and her true love murdered.  And it’s all boring as hell.

We get something in the way of consequences (although not much) when Berry tells them that Turk’s bail for Tansy’s murder has been revoked due to the whole “assaulting a cop” kerfuffle in the Napa Valley.  Naturally Rennie freaks out and tells Berry she can’t let him go to jail, the “pig of a hick deputy” started it (shades of a seven-year-old getting called on the carpet by Mommy!), and that neither of them got arrested as the result of assaulting a cop.

Bullshit Turk didn’t get arrested for that.  Bullshit Rennie didn’t get arrested for that.  This is the heavy hand of the author making sure Patricia and Jim—whoops, Turk and Rennie—never have to deal with setbacks the way we ordinary peons do.  You know, as far as the British nobility goes, I’ve always been sort of agnostic.  I’m not for it, I’m not against it.  I’m American, so it doesn’t really have anything to do with me and I don’t really care.  I’ve never watched any of the royal weddings, didn’t watch Queen Elizabeth II’s funeral, and the only royal business I paid attention to in the past few years was the Prince Andrew scandal and, to a limited degree, Meghan Markle.  But I have to tell you, if Turk and his family were real people, I’d be yelling for tumbrels and guillotines to get rid of that bloodline forever and ever, amen.

Anyway, Turk’s just going to be under house arrest—how would they even enforce that without modern technology like ankle monitors—and Rennie still insists none of this is her queenly fault.  And I have to give Berry credit for pushing back on that, even if it’s for the wrong thing.

“It was absolutely your fault, you little butt-brain!  What the hell were you thinking, giving him head in an open car while he was driving?”  Berry whacked Rennie on the arm…

She really should be complaining about the assaulting a police officer thing. Turk mentions “the coke we dumped,” and I guess the author couldn’t be bothered to page back so she would remember that Rennie snorted most of it.  It was not dumped.

Then Berry gives us a definition of house arrest and the fact that Turk gave up his passport at some unspecified time in the past so they can’t flee the country.  Rennie and Turk are both happy that he isn’t going to be in jail like Mary Prax was.

And—chapter!  This has pissed me off no end.  It’s like Kennealy-Morrison takes pains to set up situations where, in a better book, the characters would experience the consequences of their own actions and learn from these consequences, and perhaps grow as characters as a result.  But instead of that, Rennie and Turk are given every possible dispensation, second chance, and break that they can receive, and spared from any hardships.  This isn’t a surprise, as this has been happening since the beginning of the series, but it’s so nakedly obvious here that I have no choice but to call out this poor writing of static characters, as it’s a given that neither Turk nor Rennie will ever change or grow as the author thinks they are both perfect beyond comprehension.

Since Kennealy-Morrison is so fond of literary references, here’s one that occurred to me while I was reading this chapter.

“They were careless people…they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness or whatever it was that kept them together, and let other people clean up the mess they had made…” –F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby.

Next time, chapter 21, the first chapter where Rennie does any investigating whatsoever of the murder of “one of her dearest friends.”

Love Him Madly Chapter 19, or Stupid Holiday

At this point, we are on page 299 and have 100 pages left in this book.  Chapter 25 and the epilogue don’t count as those are wrap-up and how everything turned out beautifully for Rennie.  Since Chapter 25 starts on page 376, twenty-three of those 100 pages don’t count in the mystery-solving, so we have a total of seventy-seven pages for all of the detecting in this book to take place.  That’s like a thoroughbred racehorse cropping grass at the starting gate until all the other horses are in the stretch.  There is no excuse for a book being as badly structured as this one.

For those of you who might think that Rennie will immediately follow up the clue about the Stonegemmes that she was handed as a gift by Miss Toke-One-Up, have you been reading these posts? That’s not going to happen for another two chapters.  Right now it’s time for a vacation!

Rennie sends Berry Rosenbaum to get permission for Turk to go to San Francisco with her, so apparently she can give Berry instructions and she will carry them out.  Why did she never go to Internal Affairs about Marcus’s conflict of interest? I can understand why Rennie didn’t do any stories about it, but she could have tried to do something to get Marcus removed other than trust in the author—whoops, I meant trust in Marcus’s inner morality.  This is so poorly written I don’t even know who Berry’s contacting about this.  I guess she’d speak to the District Attorney’s office, but I can’t prove it from the text.

Berry agreed that it was not out of line, as long as they kept their word about checking in twice daily, and she put in a few calls.

And when did Turk give his word? And why would Rennie need to call in? She isn’t out on bail.  I don’t like the use of “they” and “their” here, even if they are a couple.  Turk’s the only one that’s bound by the bail legally.

So the next week (it feels like we’re into late May or early June by now, with the next book starting in December of 1968) they’re tooling up the Pacific Coast Highway (and not doing cocaine while navigating un-guardrailed thousand-foot drops yet) in his Porsche convertible with the top down.

We’re told they got “ten business days of precious freedom” with actually is sixteen if the weekends are included and I’m at a loss as to what’s going on with that tour that Lionheart’s supposed to be going on.  It seemed to be a little more imminent in the last chapter, but fuck it, I guess, because Rennie and Turk’s vacation is more important.  Isn’t it fun to be rich and not have to work for a living?

Especially the Robinhood family!

On the way up they stay in Monterey and we get the most extensive reference to the second book that we’ve had in this book.  They spend three days in Carmel (this is five days into the 16-day trip, so we have 11 days left in this stupid vacation) at the Highlands Inn (a real hotel) and “avoided Otter Cove,” which isn’t.  I almost forgot that Turk was in the second book and knows what a moron Rennie was about Finn Hanley.  How he can think she’s intelligent is a mystery to me, even without the “moving in with a guy you’ve met four times and fucked once.”

In the next section they get into San Francisco and Rennie starts running down Los Angeles (again) and flashes some more literary cred (this time it’s Gertrude Stein, and again, Rennie wasn’t a lit major in college).  They go to her ridiculously cheap six-room apartment on Buena Vista Way with a view of the Golden Gate Bridge and we get a recap of the name-dropping for the building (Mark Twain and Jack London).  They take a walk through Buena Vista Park and Turk’s okay with it, but Rennie goes into a little depth about why she loves it.  I’d love anyplace I could rent a six-room top-floor apartment with a view of the Golden Gate Bridge that I could afford if I were a starving journalist.

She does remember somebody almost killed him, however, and is checking for watchers in cars, which she calls “caution, or paranoia.”  Then the next two pages are Rennie showing Turk around her six-room apartment, which of course he loves.  Everything’s presentable because she “employed a lovely gay guy doing business as Vance the House Elf to come in every week to dust and hoover and water the plants.”  Are there any gay guys who are creeps in this universe, other than Danny Marron?

We get the note that she’d “upgraded from her original street finds,” and while she did have some of those, Stephen gave her a lot of furniture from the Hall Place attics and, when Jasper Alan Rickman Goring and Not Frankie Avalon got murdered in her living room, replaced all the furniture after she gave him permission to fix things.  That’s kind of a retcon of omission.

Rennie’s thinking about giving it up because she isn’t there often enough—wow!  That’s something I thought of the second she told us she was moving to Los Angeles.  Why have an apartment that you barely use? But then she goes back on her thought and advises she’ll be keeping it for a while.  Well, that was worth the amount of page you used for it, Ms. Kennealy-Morrison!

Turk agrees she shouldn’t and her grandmother’s Staffordshire teapot gets a mention.  Do all Anglophiles love tea as much as this trick?

Anyway, she floats the idea of renting a place in Los Angeles other than the cottage at Mary Prax’s and he gets anxious and reminds her they’re living together.  This is a nice little piece of manipulation on her part—making him aware that she has other options and may choose to exercise them.  She then goes on to tell him that “people should have a neutral zone for their relationship” (that’s called a hotel) and that she misses her things.  Then why didn’t you bring them down to LA when you moved into the Beverly Hillbillies mansion’s cottage? Because you were keeping your options open, that’s why.

Turk is explicitly said to feel “panic” and spends a couple of paragraphs in this state, which is what Rennie intended, but the author can maintain plausible deniability as this is all from Turk’s POV.  He asks if she wants to move out of Nichols Canyon, which is the obvious question. 

Now that she knows her tactic succeeded, she instantly takes it back and claims she doesn’t want to move out and is just concerned that they’ll wind up blending into each other and lose individual identity, which is pretty stupid but he goes for it and basically proposes.  Way to go, Rennie! Now I know why we had this chapter with the side quest to San Francisco!  So he and she spend the last couple of paragraphs talking about their worries for the future (he) and their reassurances (she).

The next section involves Turk and Rennie fucking in her “own bed” (why didn’t she have it sent to her in LA? Maybe because this isn’t a permanent move there and she knows it?) and he doesn’t like her girly flower-print sheets because he’s a man.  At least she doesn’t change them to please His Lordship.

Turk doesn’t want to let Rennie drive his precious car the next day, as that might cause his penis to shrink, but he does and is then confident of her ability to drive in the town that she lived in for over a year.  Of course they go by Hall Place and the Lacings reenter the story.

Eric Lacing, Rennie’s gay brother-in-law who’s been outed against his will twice by his sister-in-law, agreed to dinner with Rennie and Turk and there’s some talk about his marriage to Petra, a lesbian, and their six-month-old son Thomas, “known familially as Tizzy.”  As I said when this was first mentioned, congratulations on your future school years, kid, which will be filled with schoolyard beatings! 

Their respective lovers, Eric’s boyfriend Trey and Petra’s girlfriend Davina Shores, are also married to each other.  The original plan was to all move into a house together, but that’s out the window since Eric and Petra decided to live at Hall Place and birth heirs to the Lacing family name, but Rennie somehow thinks it’s worked out beautifully for everyone concerned and sees it as a huge joke on Marjorie Lacing, her once and future enemy because Marjorie didn’t worship her and had a clear-eyed notion of what kind of person Rennie is. Did I say I like Marjorie Lacing? Because I do.

The next section is two pages of Turk and Rennie having fun in San Francisco because what’s a murder charge hanging over a person’s head? Nothing to worry about!  This adds nothing at all to the story, except to note that Rennie takes Ling’s remarriage bribe from the second book, a white jadeite vase, with her when they leave for the Napa Valley and the second leg of their vacation.

They’re staying at a place called Lilac Cottage in the Napa Valley, which turns out to be a guest cottage at the Lacing family “retreat” Whiteoaks.  Although it’s a cottage, it has ten bedrooms and Eric agreed to lend it out because he and Trey would be up there later.  For whatever reason, Turk is wary of the cottage and starts asking about Stephen, but Rennie isn’t shown as picking up on his insecurity here.  And why shouldn’t he be? She has refused to divorce Stephen for two straight years, despite her repeated adulteries and desertion of him.  But somehow what she tells him reassures him and they decide to go inside and unpack.

And—chapter!  Wow, this is the most worthless chapter in the book.  There is no goddamned reason for any of this to be here.  The actual reason they’re up here doesn’t show itself until the next chapter and is the inciting reason for Rennie getting off her lazy ass to try figuring out who killed “one of her dearest friends,” who could have been a cold case to this day for all she actually cares.  Any editor worth their salt would have told her to cut this chapter entirely.

Next time, chapter 20, wherein Rennie insures by her own privilege and stupidity that Turk violates his bail provisions, but don’t worry, neither of them will suffer the kind of consequences we would, as we aren’t the King and Queen of Author Self-Inserts.

Love Him Madly Chapter 18, or the Rennie Horror Music Show

That one shot at Turk didn’t do much damage because the first sentence notes it’s fixed in the morning and they’re getting more alarms.  I’m not sure why they haven’t noticed this, but they had alarms when Stalker Lady was coming by every day, when Stalker Lady came by once a week, and when Stalker Lady took a shot at Turk.  GIVE UP ON THE GODDAMNED ALARMS!

Turk reads the reviews, which are “glowing” as he is King Gary Stu, and goes down to his studio to work, which Rennie seems a little miffed about as he isn’t comforting her and she is the center of the universe.  But the next paragraph indicates she has work to do too, so why is she copping an attitude over this?

Anyway, they’re putting in “bullet-resistant glass” and a new window frame and she’s trying to get a story on Bob Dylan transcribed while War God Cherry Blossom and the workmen are making noise and bustling around.  Hey, didn’t she have a writing room in one of the turrets of this non-castle? Why doesn’t she go up there?

But Rennie doesn’t think of that and decides to blow off work to go shopping.  Her haul is “a jade saddle ring for Turk, a silver tea service for the house and two pairs of jade earrings for herself.”  She already has two tea services, one Wedgwood and one Staffordshire.  How many does she need?

There’s some recap about what happened with the police, which isn’t much, and Rennie lets her paranoia free when she thinks:

…if Marcus had had a hand in, well, maybe not the actual shooting—though she wouldn’t put anything past him at this point—but at least in the stonewalling they were now getting from the cop shop.

Ohhhhh, I get why Marcus followed Rennie to Los Angeles and presented himself as a pseudo-stalker now.  Kennealy-Morrison wants us to view him as a suspect.  It’s not the worst idea, and in other hands it could have worked, but here Marcus Dorner is too much of a hollow cardboard character for us to believe him as a stalker-killer.  We don’t have any insight into his passions or obsessions, which Kennealy-Morrison tried to do in the scene where he tells Rennie he’s convinced Turk murdered Tansy, but it just doesn’t work.  Plus, there’s no hint in Rennie’s thoughts that either she or the author thinks she’s being irrational here.

Right before the end of the section was something amusing.  Rennie’s all upset because they’re having to stay in the house due to the attempted murder and pipes up with:

“Murders, shootings, gassings, stalkings, thefts…who’s doing it, and why are they doing it, and why can’t we make them stop?”

But he had no answer.

Yeah, that’s really the only way Rennie gets answers—being given them by someone else.  It’s not like she’s an investigative journalist who could, you know, investigate this.  But I can tell you why you can’t make them stop—because you have no idea who they are and haven’t really tried to find out.

The next section concerns Mary Prax arranging for her band (I guess it’s still Evenor although Kennealy-Morrison doesn’t remind us what their name is) to be the opening act for Bluesnroyals, which is Ned Raven’s band.  Everybody thinks this is a great idea and Ned is described here as “an old friend of Turk and Prax as well as an old, though brief, flame of Rennie’s.”  This is kind of a retcon as he’s one of Rennie’s casual starfucks from the first book and sounded like a perfect asshole during a telephone conversation with Rennie during the second book.  Brian Jones of the Rolling Stones, who was a two-night stand of Rennie’s, was also described as a “former flame.”

Rennie’s having dinner in Chinatown (no specific restaurant) with Mary Prax, Jacinta O’Malley the Stalker Lady, and Christabel Green (Francher Green’s wife) and is bitching about Mary Prax and Turk being out on the road performing while she has nothing to do but sit at home and calls them both “selfish pigs.”  Takes one to know one.  Mary Prax offers to let Rennie come with her and she refuses as she hates the road.  So what are they supposed to do? You refuse to change your situation and do nothing but bitch at your best friend because she isn’t obeying your wishes? This is supposed to come across as friendly repartee but Rennie’s so relentlessly hostile I don’t think the writer knows how to do that.

Mary Prax suggests Rennie take herself off to New York as both she and Turk’s bands will be playing there during their tours.  Rennie doesn’t agree immediately as she’s thinking, Persuade me, coax me, talk me into it…

Why does everybody have to cater to your lazy ass? Your parents are in New York.  I would ask if she doesn’t want to see them, but there’s never been a hint in the entire series that she gives a single shit about them.  We don’t even know what their names are.  They’ve called a few times as the writer’s advised us in summary, but they’ve never had any actual dialogue.

So Jacinta speaks up and has a longish paragraph about all the things that Rennie can do in New York City.  She hasn’t had a lot of dialogue and has basically hung out in the background so as not to draw the reader’s eye to her as a suspect, which I don’t think is playing fair with the audience, especially in view of the fact that it’s now chapter 18.

Then Rennie frets about wanting to get Turk out of town and being tempted to go to New York.  Wait a minute, on the previous page she just said she wanted to get Turk on a plane to Maui but couldn’t due to the bail restrictions.  So is he being allowed to leave Los Angeles to perform in the tour that  was already set up? Then she has this line.

The idea of Marcus going on the road with them, as an official LAPD chaperone, or warden, was too horrible to contemplate.

And also too stupid.  There’s no way that the LAPD is going to take a detective off all his active cases—he has to have more than just Tansy and Not Danny Sugerman and Citrine and Amethyst—to supervise a rock star.  Also, why hasn’t Rennie had her fancy-pants highly-paid lawyer and second-best friend Berry Rosenbaum go down to the LAPD and talk to Internal Affairs about Marcus concealing a past sexual relationship with the girlfriend of a murder suspect and possibly having lost objectivity in the case.  If nothing else, this gives the appearance of misconduct and could hurt any case the DA might make against Turk later.

Then we shift into six pages of talk that in places touches on the actual murder and could loosely be considered headwork, which is part of detecting.  It’s still too little too late as far as I’m concerned but whatever.

The talk amounts to Rennie not believing Amethyst is dead and rehashing the fact that Stalker Lady can get onto and off the property whenever she wants, no matter how many gates and alarms Rennie wastes Turk’s money on.

Jacinta points out that Rennie’s wearing the Tarrant family seal and we get some details about what it looks like.

“You may kiss it if you like,” Rennie loftily informed her.

And then we find out that the necklace Rennie stole from Tansy’s possessions after she died has gone missing, presumably at the same time as Turk’s pistols.  Of course, she doesn’t phrase it that way.

…I can’t find that necklace of Tansy’s—you know, the one that Tokie bequeathed me at the Chateau wake.

Miss Toke-One-Up didn’t bequeath you anything—she told you to take what you wanted from Tansy’s possessions, possibly without the permission of the family, but Kennealy-Morrison is trying to get that act of theft in under the Mystic Native American exemption.  And the theft of Rennie’s stolen property is just an excuse for some jewel porn.

…Stephen’s diamonds and my Grandma Vinnie’s sapphire ring and that diamond heart that Turk gave me for my birthday…a family heirloom that Queen Victoria laid on a Tarrant bridesmaid at some princess’s wedding…

Then Rennie clarifies the necklace went missing the same night Turk’s guns did.  I didn’t get the idea Turk knew when the guns were taken, just when he noticed they were gone.  And she decides to throw some suspicion on Rose Red Herring.  It might be nice if we thought this was based on anything but her jealousy of the other woman.  She’s mealy-mouthed and says she isn’t “accusing” Rose of anything except having the flaming panties for Turk, which isn’t illegal no matter what Rennie would like.

Jacinta articulates that Rennie’s saying she thinks Rose Red Herring is Stalker Lady, and Rennie is “staggered that they seemed to be taking her suggestion very seriously indeed.”  Why? You’ve already established that you’re the alpha female around here and the others are forbidden to have thoughts or opinions that don’t match yours under penalty of being evil.

So the other women start detecting and Rennie puts herself in the devil’s advocate position by defending Rose even though she was the one who suggested Rose as a suspect in the first place.  And we are informed that the gate codes for Turk’s not-castle are in the possession of most of Greater Los Angeles. 

Christabel Green indicates she doesn’t think Rose is the type, which gives Rennie the opportunity once more to flaunt her Murder Chick credentials and tell them nobody looks like the type.  Mary Prax asks Rennie if she’s saying Rose is Stalker Lady and Rennie waffles.  Jacinta suggests jealousy as the motive.  Is it a shame that most of the detective work in this book has been done by Christabel, Jacinta, and Mary Prax, with Rennie sitting there twiddling her thumbs?

The next section starts at the LA Forum show where Ned Raven and Bluesnroyals is playing.  Somehow Rennie gets backstage because she’s “family,” which she isn’t but whatever.  Ned’s with his wife Demelza Rhys-Jones (somebody saw Poldark) and here’s how he greets Rennie.

“Renners!  How about a quick one, you sexy gorgeous thing? For auld lang syne? Come on, beautiful, there’s the couch, let’s go, on your back, knickers off!  Once I get me trousers zipped that’s it for the night.”

Yeah, he’s kidding and his wife laughs along with Rennie, but it’s still pretty tacky.  Can you imagine how Rennie would have flipped the fuck out if one of Turk’s casual lays came on to him like this?  Plus, the “auld lang syne” reference is the same one Rennie made to Marcus when he came to Nichols Canyon to confront her about lying, and the whole structure of the dialogue is reminiscent of Sharon from the first book telling Rennie how to arrange herself when the woman is painting her naked.

Ned is just wildly happy about Rennie getting with Turk, which proves the writer doesn’t know much about men.  There’s some overwritten dialogue between Ned and Rennie about the murders and eventually she kisses him, just in time for Turk, Mary Prax, and War God Cherry Blossom to be cued and enter, all grinning broadly.  I am sick of all of them grinning, and I am sick of Kennealy-Morrison’s adverb abuse.

In the next section, Rennie’s taken a seat in the Forum before the show and Marcus turns up.  Turns out he’s the one who was watching Turk and Rennie fuck.  She responds, of course, with the graceless bitchiness that we’re used to and we get almost a page in Marcus’s POV about watching them fuck.  It’s just embarrassing how intent the writer is on pounding into our heads that Marcus will never never never get over Rennie because she is just that much better than any other woman.

Rennie reluctantly asks Marcus for permission to take Turk to San Francisco and he admits he’s off the case, but only because he was too moral to continue on the case, to the point of telling them he’d “quit the force,” as the LAPD was fine with such a clear-cut conflict of interest that could endanger any case the DA could make against Turk.  What universe are we in again?

Somebody sits down next to Rennie after Marcus goes to his own seat and—oh God.  It’s Miss Toke-One-Up, “fashionable in head-to-toe Rive Gauche.”  So she’s naked except for perfume she’s sprayed all over herself?

If you mean she was wearing Yves St. Laurent, the designer who created Rive Gauche (which wasn’t launched until 1971 BTW), or haute couture, then you should have said that.  Rennie calls her Foxy Lady because Tokalah means fox in Lakota Sioux, which it does, according to Google.  And then we get about a paragraph about what happened to Tansy’s band Moonfyre (exactly what Rennie said) and Turnstone (Miss Toke-One-Up is now the co-lead singer).  It’s all very uninteresting.

Then we find out why Miss Toke-One-Up reappeared in the narrative—it’s to dispense some clues as she points out some other members of the Stonegemmes.  Why does Rennie the Murder Chick need to be taken by the hand and guided to clues? Anyway, Miss Toke-One-Up drops the information that several of the Stonegemmes were at the Whisky the night Tansy was murdered but can’t tell Rennie which ones and Rennie cuts at her with a reference to having seen Tansy hanging and Miss Toke-One-Up is unsettled and leaves pretty shortly afterward.  I’m glad Miss Toke-One-Up got even a little comeuppance for telling people to steal Tansy’s stuff.

Then we get a page and a half of Rennie wondering about the Stonegemmes and running down groupies.  Kennealy-Morrison tells us that Rennie’s engaged in physical violence against groupies in an attempt to keep them away from Turk, with the fig leaf that they started it (like any six-year-old would protest) and of course wiped the floor with them because War God Cherry Blossom taught her how to fight and because she is Queen Mary Sue.  This is a woman who’s so insecure she should never be involved with any musician because if she can’t deal with groupies when Turk doesn’t want to fuck them, she certainly will not be able to deal with ordinary fans who want to do the same thing.

Then we get almost a page of Evenor’s triumphant showing as the second opening act for Bluesnroyals, then Ned Raven and his band go on and do an impromptu cover of “Bend Don’t Break.”

And—chapter!  Man, she’s got seven chapters and an epilogue now and she’s only just thought of looking into the Stonegemmes, and she wouldn’t have if Miss Toke-One-Up hadn’t spoon-fed her the clue.  Why was she not looking into them after Citrine died in the bed? She knew Amethyst had been stalking Turk. How long is it going to take before she makes some actual progress? This is the worst paced book of the series so far.

I get the feeling that if she and Turk hadn’t been attacked, Rennie would be peachy-keen with sitting on her ass cooking for her man and getting rammed while Tansy’s murderer went free.  I understand her not giving a shit about Not Danny Sugerman, since she hated him, or Citrine, since she felt contempt for her because she was a sexually liberated woman who had sex with men when she felt like it and exposed Rennie’s hypocrisy regarding sex, but, again, she loudly proclaimed Tansy “one of her dearest friends.”

Next time, chapter 19, wherein Rennie and Turk go to San Francisco (so I guess those bail restrictions got resolved), the Lacings show up again, and then they go to the Napa Valley because God knows there aren’t any murderers running around who need to be caught.

Love Him Madly Chapter 17, or American Sniper Lady

Lionheart’s show at the Whisky was, of course, enthralling, as King Gary Stu is the lead guitarist, and Rennie spends almost three pages rhapsodizing over it, asserting that he was better than Pete Townshend, Eric Clapton, Graham Sonnet (also known as Puce Villanelle in these posts, he’s the Paul McCartney analogue), and Jimi Hendrix.  Your mileage may vary.  We also find out that Mary Prax and War God Cherry Blossom are at the show and they are now “inseparable.”  Wow, she only “kind of” wanted him after they’d fucked three times, and now they’re inseparable? I guess Mary Prax gets dickmatized pretty quick.  We also find out the name of one of their songs, “Danger Money,” which they pull a Grateful Dead on and do a ten-minute bridge for, which everyone loves, as Lionheart is the biggest and bestest rock band ever, you guys!

Rennie also muses to herself that his music is the reason she’s in love with him.  Really? So if you meet a better musician, you’ll leave Turk for him? What if the better musician is a woman? All questions that will never be answered.  She also makes this mental crack.

…for the first time ever, tonight I actually got to say, ‘I’m with the band,’ for that special groupie thrill.

I don’t even know what to do with that in view of her much-expressed hatred toward groupies.  The only thing I can think of is to mention that I’m With the Band was the title of Pamela Des Barres’s memoir, who was a groupie and fucked Jim Morrison on occasion.

Since Rennie’s in a good mood from the successful show, Mary Prax takes the opportunity to clue her in that Marcus was at the show “all night,” and Rennie tells her friend, “I’d have smacked him around like a cat toy.”  In your keyboard warrior dreams, sweetie.

We also find out that apparently Marcus is still on the case, despite having concealed a prior sexual relationship with the suspect’s girlfriend.  Rennie only gives that a minute’s thought before going to hunt down Turk so they can go to the after-party at the Brown Derby.

Rennie finds Turk sitting on the stairs backstage and experiencing some grief over Tansy, which Rennie sympathizes with before they go under the staircase to fuck standing up and be watched by Stalker Lady.  And Rennie knows that they’re being watched by somebody but is too into the sex to care.

This marks the first explicit sex scene in the series so far.  It doesn’t strike me as being as rough as she’s indicated she likes earlier in the series, but there’s no foreplay whatsoever, just wham-bam-thank-you-ma’am, which she is completely down with and from which she has a huge orgasm.  I’m not sure why the writer decided to go the explicit sex route here (and it isn’t as explicit as a lot of these scenes in other books:  no description of genitalia, no detailing of every thrust), unless she’s trying to suggest that Rennie never had any satisfactory sex before, which she has indicated that she did.  Maybe it’s just because Stalker Lady’s watching (or someone we assume is) and we have to understand that this backstage sex scene is the reason why she’s going to ramp up the violence later in this chapter.

During the session, Rennie thinks that somebody watching them makes the sex better.  And also this.

…if this doesn’t exorcise Tansy’s ghost from the Whisky forever—it’ll either make her really, really happy or really, really pissed off—I don’t know what will.  But either way she won’t be back…

It’s kind of uncomfortable that this scene, which could be read as an attempt to comfort Turk over his grief, can also be read as Rennie’s attempt to win a victory over Tansy in death by rubbing her ghostly nose in her ex-boyfriend fucking somebody else and forcing her out of the place where she died with no concern for where she would go afterward.  This is “one of her dearest friends,” too.

Also, although Rennie might be getting a big sexual charge out of someone watching her fuck her boyfriend, Turk might not.  Is this why she didn’t just yell, “Get out!” over his shoulder when she spotted the observer? That would have given Turk a choice as to whether to allow someone to continue to watch him fucking his girlfriend or not, and Rennie wasn’t down with that.  In fact, what he wants in regard to this never entered her mind.

They never say anything to each other during or after the sex session and when Rennie looks over to where the observer was, there’s nobody there.

But, interestingly enough, in Rennie’s mind she doesn’t realize that this could have been a real person, maybe even the person who’s been leaving presents at Turk’s place and possibly murdering four people, and seems to think Tansy’s ghost was watching, which makes the whole thing even meaner-spirited.  She reiterates in her mind that she’s Turk’s woman and the ghost is gone.

Somewhere in Malibu, Zombie Tansy reforms her body from the ashes and rises from the Pacific Ocean to take slow steps up the beach, bound for Nichols Canyon to do mayhem.

So the Whisky’s deserted when they’re done except for Mary Prax and War God Cherry Blossom, who are sniggering in a knowing, superior way at all the sex Rennie and Turk had.  In my opinion, that’s not a very sex-positive attitude, but I don’t think the writer had one of those herself.  Turk doesn’t want to go to the Brown Derby after-party and tells Rennie she and Mary Prax and War God Cherry Blossom should go to the after-after party at David Crosby’s and he’ll go home alone.  War God Cherry Blossom and Rennie both shit all over that notion and tell him that he has to make an appearance at the party since he’s “the star of the evening” and then they can go home if he wants.

Once they get home, we’re introduced to the guy who’s War God Cherry Blossom’s “second-in-command.”  Since every new character is worse than the one that came before, here’s our intro to him.

…a huge, genial, powerfully built Hawaiian who rejoiced in the name of Rhino Kanaloa…

He just seems quite unlikely, as well as a new member of the Cool Horde gathering around Rennie and Turk.  That’s what I’m calling the band of loyal Rennie-worshippers that she will collect to herself.

Then we get an uninteresting scene of Rennie making club steaks, crab cakes, and pasta, while Kanaloa gets chocolate-dipped strawberries and whipped cream, and Mary Prax makes tea and coffee.  This seems like a pretty elaborate dinner to be put together on the fly, and she gets the plot back on track by alluding to having a bad feeling and getting in another shot at Tansy.

 Maybe Tansy, having been ghostbusted from the Whisky by the power of lust, was getting ready to manifest herself here, as a poltergeist or maybe a succubus, or just one of those spooky cold spots, a damp and dreary stain on the stone floor?

She’s picturing “one of her dearest friends” as a damp stain on a floor.  The succubus image is revealing as indicative of what Rennie sees as Tansy’s sexual power, and it’s telling that Rennie claims that her friend was banished from the place she haunted “by the power of lust.”  Lust, not love.  It’s Rennie trying to equal Tansy in her ability to provoke passion, not love.  And there is no love in Rennie for Tansy, no matter how much she trumpets their friendship.

And Zombie Tansy is still coming for you.  It’s only a matter of time.

Turk’s sitting outside in a pool of light and Rennie gets pissed because he’s making a target of himself and gets irritated with War God Cherry Blossom for allowing it.  Look, Turk is his boss.  He can suggest something, but he can’t physically force him to do anything.  If it’s something he feels strongly about, he can threaten to quit if Turk doesn’t abide by what he wants, but he can’t flat-out force his employer to do it.

Turk agrees with Rennie in his mind that Tansy’s been banished from the Whisky and we get about a page and a half about what performing and its aftermath is like for a rock star before we finally get to the dramatic high point of this chapter.

Turk goes to pick some jasmine for Rennie and somebody takes a shot at him.  He isn’t hurt, just falls to the ground as he’s overbalanced.  Normally, this is where Kennealy-Morrison would end the chapter and the next chapter would start out with a time jump before we got back to what happened next.  War God Cherry Blossom and Rhino, respectively, turn off the lights and knock both Rennie and Mary Prax to the floor.  Mary Prax is depicted as dumb enough to think this is an earthquake, but Rennie’s fighting to get to Turk as she’s the smartest Mary Sue ever and has been paranoid about him getting killed since they met.  War God Cherry Blossom orders her, and everyone else, to get inside the house, but she’s Queen Mary Sue and she doesn’t have to listen.

Rennie freaks out about Turk getting shot at, he quips and calms her down to the point where they’re laughing when War God Cherry Blossom comes back from searching the grounds.  Turns out Stalker Lady somehow got hold of one of Turk’s James Bond automatics and popped off a shot at him.  My question is, why did she drop the gun? She might be able to use it again later, or at least find a better place to dispose of it if Turk is actually dead.

War God Cherry Blossom takes him to task for not turning over the Walthers and Turk says he couldn’t find them.  Why was he not bothered by the fact that two of his guns went missing?  The bodyguard didn’t bother checking on this either so it’s not 100% Turk’s fault. 

Rennie drops some more literary cred (why, yes, it’s Tolkien, why do you ask?) and then notices Turk is bleeding and freaks out again.  War God Cherry Blossom assures him it’s just a cut on his forehead from flying glass and tries to get everybody back in the house with Rhino’s help but Rennie insists on freaking out on the terrace in full view of any possible snipers until the section ends.

The next section starts with a page’s worth of recounting of Turk’s visit to the Cedars ER (not calling it Cedars of Lebanon anymore somehow) to get his head stitched up and the glass removed from Rennie’s knees.  It’s uninteresting. 

War God Cherry Blossom’s people secure the house and do searches, and have acquired a German shepherd.  Mary Prax isn’t allowed to leave and everybody’s trying to go to sleep but Rennie can’t and resorts to her usual hyperbolic threats of violence.

Somebody tried to KILL him…when I find out who, I will rip their heart out still beating and hold it aloft like a game-winning baseball…

Not if your track record up until this point is any indicator.

Anyway, she leaves Turk alone to check on Mary Prax and then go downstairs to check on the bodyguards, and War God Cherry Blossom tells her to go back to sleep and she does.

And—chapter!  We are now eight chapters and an epilogue from the end of this book and there has still been no detecting on Rennie’s part.  I’m not counting either the last chapter or the epilogue, as the pattern for these books has been for these to be all about how beautifully things have turned out for Rennie.  So there are a maximum of seven chapters in which the writer has to come up with some more suspects for the murders and the attacks on Rennie and/or Turk, investigate them to the point where she can decide whodunit, and have Rennie preen over her own intelligence while she describes to the police and all her friends how she figured everything out. 

The only two suspects we’ve been given at this point—other than Turk, who Rennie will never countenance any suspicion of—are Rose Red Herring and Amethyst, and Rennie isn’t even doing anything to investigate them.  She hasn’t checked alibis for any of the murders, hasn’t figured out if either of them has the mechanical knowledge to set up vents to gas Not Danny Sugerman, hasn’t tried to find out if Rose had any prior relationships with Citrine (we know Amethyst did), hasn’t tried to get any deep background on either of them (she doesn’t even know where Amethyst is from, other than “the Midwest,” which to a New York chauvinist like Rennie is a vast undifferentiated space of corn and cattle), and hasn’t tried staking Rose out to see if she’ll reveal anything if she’s followed. 

Rennie should be perceptive enough to see a connection to the Stonegemmes, with Amethyst having stalked Turk and Citrine turning up dead in their house.  As soon as Citrine turned up dead, she should have been delving into the backgrounds of every other groupie associated with them in hopes of turning up some information.  She should be acting like an investigative journalist here, but she’s too busy getting rammed by a belted earl.

And that fig leaf about Rennie not having connections in Los Angeles the way she did in San Francisco?  She didn’t have any connections in San Francisco either; Ken Karper, the crime beat reporter at the Clarion, had connections, so she sucked up to him to get him to use those connections for her benefit.  Doesn’t Baron Hollywood Hogan have any newspapers down here with crime beat reporters who aren’t immune to a pretty face that she could use? This is making me wonder if Rennie is even going to be the one who solves the mystery this time, and by solves the mystery I mean has the killer take her prisoner and confess to her, as happened in the last two books. 

Next time, chapter 18, in which the positioning of Rose Red Herring as a suspect goes into high gear, Ned Raven of Bluesnroyals turns up (wish it was Owen Danes instead—I don’t much care for Ned), and we find out people were running all around the backstage area and seeing Rennie and Turk fucking.